Should the US legalize the sale of organs?

Legalizing organ trade in the U.S. could be a viable option to satisfy stakeholders through compensation, greater organ supply, and reduced loss of life. However, legalizing the sale of organs presents many ethical dilemmas through exploitation and possible violations of human rights.

Why should sale of human organs be legalized?

The poor will be exploited, forced to sell their organs. It might bring them money but they will end up risking their own health. Those in need of human organs cannot rely on altruism alone; there must also be a legal system to create the necessary supply. The sale of human organs should indeed be legalised.

Why is it illegal to sell your organs in the United States?

Why is it illegal to sell organs? According to the Health Resources and Services Administration, “One reason Congress made this law was to make sure the wealthy do not have an unfair advantage for obtaining donated organs and tissues”.

Is selling organs legal in the US?

In the United States such sales are illegal under the National Organ Transplant Act. Encouraging “donation” by offering any sort of payment is also illegal. Many people object to a free market in organs for several reasons. Third, poor people sell their organs today, but they do it on the black market.

What is the problem with organ sales?

Arguments against organ sale are grounded in two broad considerations: (1) sale is contrary to human dignity, and (2) sale violates equity. Both these objections are examined in this article and it is concluded that they reflect a state of moral paternalism rather than pragmatism.

Is selling human organs moral?

Today, said Kerstein, “selling organs is wrong in the current context it is likely to occur.” That is — with little respect for human dignity, particularly for the dignity of the poor. But perhaps there are permissible alternatives to buying and selling organs, he said.