Can killing be morally justified?

As Lazar asserts, to kill in any context other than in war, or in self-defence[1] during ordinary circumstances, is a violation of our duty to uphold the right of others to life (Lazar 2009: 699-700). This implies that killing during war can be morally justified, at a minimum through appeals to self-defence.

Are some crimes justifiable?

Justification is an exception to the prohibition of committing certain offenses. When an act is justified, a person is not criminally liable even though their act would otherwise constitute an offense. For example, to intentionally commit a homicide would be considered murder.

Do you believe Montresor’s revenge was justified?

In “The Cask of Amontillado,” revenge is not justified. The narrator, Montresor, tells his listener that Fortunato had he had borne…

Is war ethically justified?

A war is only just if it is fought for a reason that is justified, and that carries sufficient moral weight. The country that wishes to use military force must demonstrate that there is a just cause to do so. Sometimes a war fought to prevent a wrong from happening may be considered a just war.

Is necessity a justification defense?

Because the defense of necessity is essentially a justification for the criminal act, it is imperative that the defendant had no other realistic options available to him at the time the criminal act was committed. If he did, his criminal actions would not be justified.

Is insanity a justification defense?

The insanity defense refers to a defense that a defendant can plead in a criminal trial. In an insanity defense, the defendant admits the action but asserts a lack of culpability based on mental illness. The insanity defense is classified as an excuse defense, rather than a justification defense.

Was Montresor justified in killing Fortunato?

Although Poe never explains what injuries Montresor has endured from Fortunato, context clues imply that not only has Fortunato bore harm upon Montresor but also his family. So when Fortunato insults Montresor he is justified in his actions to rid him of his problem.