Did Molly really tell the Pinkertons?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch Van der Linde’s girlfriend Molly O’Shea told a grave lie about the Pinkertons that cost the woman her life. Molly O’Shea’s story came to an abrupt end in Red Dead Redemption 2, but not before the gang member told a serious lie that ended up costing her life.

Who is the traitor in rdr2?

Micah
Micah manages to stab Arthur in the chest during this struggle before Dutch arrives to break up the fight. With his dying breaths, Arthur swears that Micah is the traitor and begs Dutch to kill him, but Dutch abandons them both.

Can you save Lenny on the roof?

Unfortunately not. Lenny is going to die in Red Dead Redemption 2, no matter what you do. It doesn’t matter whether you, as Arthur, ride around aiding the innocent or shoot strangers in the face as soon as you see them; every scripted death in the game is unpreventable.

Why did Micah become rat?

Well according to Milton, They picked up Micah when they returned from Guarma, and i think that Micah ratted out the gang because he was afraid he would be killed if he didn’t.

Does Molly O’Shea have a grave?

Molly is the only member of the gang who died in 1899 not to be buried. Instead, Miss Grimshaw orders Bill and Pearson to burn her body. This is most likely because she was believed to have given information to the Pinkertons and was therefore not worthy of a proper burial.

Can I save Hosea?

Because Lenny and Hosea die as part of enormous scripted cutscenes (and ones that are integral to how the rest of RDR2’s story plays out, too), there’s no action the player can take that changes the events of the game.

Did Micah work for the Pinkertons?

There is no evidence whatsoever (not that I’m saying that you advocate this) to say that Micah ever worked with the Pinkertons post-1899. Micah also kills a still-alive Pinkerton at Lakay after the assault, but this is not only logical, but to be expected.